Curriculum
Course: Crypto Wallets
Login

Curriculum

Crypto Wallets

Video lesson

Seed Phrase Security

The True Future of Secure Seed Phrase Storage: Unpacking Shamir Secret Sharing

Introduction: From Security to Simplicity

In the vast world of cryptocurrency, where fortunes can change in a heartbeat, the security of your assets is paramount. Imagine leaving your prized possession—your seed phrase—unattended in a crowded marketplace. Just like a lost key to a vault, if it falls into the wrong hands, it could lead to a heist of epic proportions. In today’s lesson, we will explore an innovative solution to secure your seed phrases, namely Shamir Secret Sharing (SSS), a method that stands far superior to common homemade strategies like the 2 out of 3 split.

Through this exploration, you will learn how to bolster the security of your crypto assets, understand the math and crypto principles behind SSS, and ultimately, why you might want to avoid simpler methods that compromise your safety. Your key takeaways from this lesson include:

  1. Understanding SSS and its benefits.
  2. Recognizing the pitfalls of homemade methods.
  3. Gaining practical knowledge on how to implement SSS.
  4. Evaluating your own risk tolerance regarding secure storage.

Get ready to deepen your understanding of crypto security and ensure that your digital vault remains locked tight.

What is Shamir Secret Sharing?

In this lesson, the method we’ll dissect revolves around the revolutionary technique devised by Adi Shamir: the Shamir Secret Sharing scheme (SSS). This superior approach divides your seed phrase into multiple parts or “shares,” allowing for robust security. Unlike traditional methods such as the 2 out of 3 scheme, SSS ensures that a predetermined number of shares must be combined to reveal the complete seed phrase, thereby minimizing risk and vulnerability.

The essence of the video’s message is the unique benefit of SSS. By splitting your seed phrase while adhering to mathematical foundations, you can maintain control over your assets without exposing them to potential loss. The staggering contrast between the security levels of SSS and simpler methods establishes a clear thesis: security and simplicity can coexist, but only if you choose the right method.

Steps to Secure Your Seed Phrase

To effectively utilize Shamir Secret Sharing, here’s a simple breakdown of the steps as highlighted in the lesson:

  1. Determine the number of shares: Choose how many parts you want to split your seed phrase into.
  2. Set the recovery threshold: Decide how many shares will be needed to reconstruct your seed phrase.
  3. Create the shares: Generate each share, using a word list (SLIP39) instead of the traditional BIP39 list.
  4. Distribute the shares: Store the shares safely across various locations without compromising their integrity.

This method not only secures your assets from theft but also ensures that loss of some shares doesn’t entirely jeopardize your access. It guards against both loss and malicious attack, reinforcing the strength of your security measures.

Deeper Analysis: The Power of SSS

Shamir Secret Sharing is an innovative compass in the turbulent sea of crypto security. Let’s outline its strengths and examine why it’s a crucial technique for any cryptocurrency enthusiast.

The Individual Strengths of SSS

  1. Robust Security: The method provides mathematical assurance that possessing a limited number of shares yields no useful information. For example, if you have a seed phrase split into six shares but require only three to reconstruct it, an attacker with just two shares cannot glean any information about your funds. This property fortifies your defenses against targeted attacks.

  2. Customizability and Flexibility: SSS enables users to define both the total number of shares and the threshold required for recovery. This feature allows for personal tailoring of security protocols to fit individual risk appetites. Depending on your comfort level, you might choose to carry three shares while requiring only two for reconstruction. This adaptable nature enhances usability while maintaining maximum security.

  3. Statistical Randomness: The mathematical construction underpinning SSS—polynomials—ensures that even if some shares are lost or compromised, the odds of successful recovery remain astronomically low. The inability to deduce missing data points from existing shares drastically mitigates the risk of successful brute-force attacks.

  4. Future Compatibility with Technology: As cryptocurrency technology continues to evolve, so too do the mechanisms available for securing assets. SSS is compatible with specific hardware wallets like Trezor and Keystone, paving the way for its broader adoption within the crypto community.

Areas of Contention

While SSS is lauded for its effectiveness, it’s essential to recognize a few concerns surrounding its application. First, the level of understanding required to implement SSS may deter individuals not versed in cryptography. If the procedure feels overly complex, users might be tempted to revert to easier—but less secure—methods.

Moreover, the exclusivity of current hardware integration could create barriers to entry for users who may view SSS as unnecessary or complicated to manage. It’s vital for educational outlets to clarify that understanding and implementing this technology is paramount to ensuring asset safety, especially for those investing significant funds in cryptocurrencies.

Connections to Blockchain

Delving deeper into the world of cryptocurrencies and blockchain technology, Shamir Secret Sharing provides a crucial insight into the security landscape. In a decentralized financial (DeFi) ecosystem, where smart contracts and automated systems play a pivotal role, preserving access to user wallets becomes increasingly valuable.

The Role of SSS in Decentralization

In a world governed by decentralized applications (dApps), SSS plays an essential role in fostering security. For instance, if users can manage their wallets using shares from SSS, they benefit from distributed risk management—one of the fundamental tenets of the DeFi movement. SSS creates a secure environment where individuals can mitigate vulnerabilities while enjoying the advantages of blockchain-based systems.

Real-World Applications

Numerous blockchain projects are exploring the intersections between SSS and enhanced security measures. For example, decentralized custody solutions can leverage this technology, allowing users to engage in secure storage while retaining full ownership over their assets. By using SSS alongside apt security protocols, projects can empower users while decreasing the centralization risks present in traditional financial systems.

Wider Outlook and Impact

The implications of utilizing Shamir Secret Sharing extend beyond individual asset protection to influence the broader cryptocurrency and blockchain landscapes. As the industry continues to expand, the demand for secure storage and accessible solutions will accompany its growth.

Future Shifts in Financial Security

By adopting frameworks like SSS, the future of asset security can evolve alongside technological advancements in cryptocurrencies. Using methods that prioritize cryptographic wisdom while remaining user-centric fosters an environment where more individuals feel empowered to participate in the digital economy confidently.

Moreover, should security solutions become standardized and integrated into wallets, users will inevitably enjoy enhanced confidence in managing their assets in a rapidly maturing environment. This could inspire greater participation in decentralized finance, ultimately leading to a paradigm shift in how finance operates.

Personal Commentary and Insights

As an expert navigating the ever-evolving landscape of cryptocurrencies, I have witnessed the challenges individuals face regarding security. A common narrative is the tendency to underestimate the complexity of safeguarding assets—more specifically, the dismissal of necessary security measures due to complexity or misunderstanding.

The beauty of Shamir Secret Sharing lies within its capacity to empower users while advancing decentralized finance. My observation is that the more individuals equip themselves with knowledge and understand these techniques, the better they can navigate the potential hazards of forgetting basic security measures. Embracing cryptographic principles like SSS is not merely prudent; it is vital in preserving the integrity of one’s crypto portfolio.

Conclusion: A Step Towards Secure Crypto Futures

In summary, incorporating Shamir Secret Sharing into your crypto asset management approach significantly heightens security levels compared to conventional methods. With mathematical foundations bolstering its efficacy and customized approaches enhancing user adaptability, SSS represents a critical stride towards future-proofing financial security within the digital age.

As we traverse the realms of cryptocurrencies and blockchain technology, one thing remains clear: the need for solid security protocols is non-negotiable. SSS stands at the forefront of this necessity, illuminating pathways toward empowered ownership and resilience in the face of potential threats.


Quotes:

  • “If you don’t have the full threshold, you don’t have anything.”
  • “The best protection is the one that you understand and can implement the best.”
  • “Even if an attacker is lucky enough to get his hands on only two parts, they still don’t have any information about your seed phrase.”

 

 

Securing Your Seed Phrase: Mastering Shamir Secret Sharing

In today’s rapidly evolving digital landscape, the necessity for stringent security measures has never been more paramount, especially in the realm of cryptocurrencies. This lesson explores the importance of safely storing your seed phrase — the key that unlocks your crypto assets. We will delve into Shamir Secret Sharing (SSS), a robust method that significantly enhances security compared to traditional practices like the 2-of-3 split method. Let’s embark on this enlightening journey towards safeguarding your crypto assets!

Core Concepts

  1. Seed Phrase

    • Traditional Finance: A seed phrase in finance is akin to a bank account number—it’s critical for accessing your funds.
    • Crypto Connection: In cryptocurrencies, a seed phrase is a series of words that grants access to a digital wallet. Losing it can lead to irreversible loss of funds.
  2. Shamir Secret Sharing (SSS)

    • Traditional Finance: This is not directly applicable; however, it’s similar to having multiple keys to a vault where a certain number must be used to open it.
    • Crypto Connection: SSS splits a seed phrase into multiple shares, requiring a threshold number of shares to reconstruct the original seed, enhancing security.
  3. Threshold Scheme

    • Traditional Finance: A threshold scheme in finance may refer to the minimum amount required for making transactions or withdrawals.
    • Crypto Connection: In SSS, it indicates how many shares must be combined to recreate the seed phrase, ensuring that possessing fewer shares does not compromise security.
  4. Shares

    • Traditional Finance: Shares can refer to ownership in a company, representing a portion of its assets.
    • Crypto Connection: In SSS, shares are individual segments of a seed phrase, and multiple shares can be created while ensuring that no one share reveals its entirety.
  5. BIP39 and SLIP39

    • Traditional Finance: Not a direct concept, but could relate to various industry standards for secure asset management.
    • Crypto Connection: BIP39 is a specific standard for creating mnemonic phrases for Bitcoin wallets, while SLIP39 is a variation that allows for Shamir’s method, enhancing security for seed phrases.

Understanding these concepts is vital for newcomers to crypto as it equips them with the knowledge to protect their digital assets against potential threats and malfunctions inherent in less secure methods.

Key Steps in Implementing Shamir Secret Sharing

1. Understanding the Single Point of Failure

  • Key Points:

    • A seed phrase represents a singular vulnerability.
    • Loss or theft of the seed phrase results in potential loss of funds.
  • Explanation: This single point of failure is alarming as it could initiate a sequence of adverse events. In traditional finance, losing access to your bank account number—or worse, it being stolen—could have devastating effects, just like the potential loss of crypto funds through a compromised seed phrase.

2. Evaluating Traditional Methods: The 2-of-3 Split

  • Key Points:

    • A common homemade method is to split a seed phrase into three parts, where any two parts can reconstruct the original.
    • Despite good intentions, this method severely compromises security.
  • Explanation: This method may seem appealing, but it limits the security provided by the seed phrase. Each part only offers 16 of the 24 words, significantly reducing the number of possibilities, thus weakening overall security from 256 bits to a mere 80 bits. One wouldn’t hand over the keys to the vault to three different people without utmost security—akin to how dangerous this homemade method is!

  • Crypto Connection: Relying on such a method could lead to horrible outcomes. Instead, SSS provides an incredibly robust system, ensuring that only sufficient information leads to access.

3. The Forward-Thinking Solution: Shamir Secret Sharing

  • Key Points:

    • SSS allows splitting into any number of shares with a set threshold needed for recovery.
    • Offers a greater degree of security while still being practical.
  • Explanation: The brilliance of SSS lies in its flexibility and the mathematical rigor behind it. By determining the number of shares and a threshold for recovery, individuals can safely manage their seed phrases. For example, one could split the seed into six shares while requiring just three for recovery. This way, losing a couple of shares does not endanger access to assets.

  • Crypto Connection: As crypto enthusiasts, utilizing SSS means embracing a security standard that mitigates many risks associated with traditional wallet safeguards.

4. The Math Behind SSS

  • Key Points:

    • Recovery hinges on mathematical functions called polynomials.
    • Without the complete threshold of shares, the information remains secure.
  • Explanation: Visualize this as a mathematical graph; to define a specific curve (your secret), you need a certain number of data points. Remove one, and the curve can morph into countless shapes. Similarly, without the full threshold, potential attackers face infinite guessing—much like navigating a maze without a map.

  • Crypto Connection: Understanding this adds to the cryptocurrency toolkit by clearly illustrating why SSS is more secure compared to traditional methods, as it employs advanced mathematical principles.

A Blockchain Perspective: Crypto Connection

Exploring how these principles from traditional finance align with or differ in the crypto realm can deepen understanding. For instance, SSS ensures that only by satisfying the required threshold of shares will the original information be revealed—making unauthorized access near impossible. It’s like doubling the vault doors and requiring two different keys for entry. This principle is exemplified in projects like Trezor, a hardware wallet that already supports this innovative method.

Hypothetical Examples

  1. Scenario with Traditional Method:

    • Bob splits his 24-word seed phrase into three parts, keeping two at home and one in a safe deposit box. One night, a burglar steals both home parts. Bob is left with nothing!
  2. Scenario with Shamir Secret Sharing:

    • Sarah uses SSS to split her seed into six shares, storing three in various secure locations. If one share is accidentally destroyed or stolen, she can recover her seed phrase using the remaining shares, showcasing resilience.

Real-World Applications

Historically, technology has seen a surge in demand for enhanced security, from encrypting sensitive information to implementing robust authentication measures. Similarly, crypto has evolved with heavy focus on securing user assets. The recent rise in thefts and hacks within the cryptocurrency ecosystem underscores the dire need for systems like Shamir Secret Sharing.

Cause and Effect Relationships

When a seed phrase is compromised, users lose access to funds—an immediate and direct impact. Conversely, by utilizing SSS, not only can access be correctly managed, but loss incidents diminish profoundly. Crypto projects employing these standards often see higher trust levels among users, driving adoption.

Challenges and Solutions

  • Challenges:

    • Complexity of set-up and implementation.
    • Users often prefer simplicity over security, leading to risky choices.
  • Solutions:

    • Education and intuitive design in wallet interfaces that incorporate SSS can demystify its use.
    • Common misconceptions about security levels of the two methods need addressing for informed decision-making.

Key Takeaways

  1. Secure Your Seed Phrase: Always prioritize security of your seed phrase in crypto; it’s your key.
  2. Understand SSS Importance: Shamir Secret Sharing provides advanced security unmatched by basic methods.
  3. Flexibility of Thresholds: Customize the number of shares and thresholds that suit your security needs.
  4. Future of Crypto Wallets: Hardware wallets like Trezor incorporating SSS will revolutionize security norms.
  5. Educational Resource: Stay informed about secure practices in crypto to make the best choices.
  6. Community Engagement: Discuss security methods with the crypto community to share insights and learn new strategies.

By grasping these essential points, newcomers can effectively navigate the intricate world of digital asset security.

Discussion Questions and Scenarios

  1. How does the loss of a seed phrase in crypto compare to losing access to a traditional bank account?
  2. In what situations might traditional methods like a 2-of-3 split seem like a good idea, and why are they actually harmful?
  3. Compare and contrast Shamir’s method with other security mechanisms like biometric authentication.
  4. Discuss why understanding the mathematical underpinnings of SSS offers an advantage in using it securely.
  5. Imagine a scenario where multiple hardware wallets adopt SSS. How might this impact user trust and the adoption of cryptocurrencies?

Glossary

  • Seed Phrase: A string of words that acts as a key for accessing cryptocurrency wallets.
  • Shamir Secret Sharing: A cryptographic method for dividing a secret into parts, where some parts are needed to reconstruct the original secret.
  • Threshold Scheme: A method that denotes how many shares are needed to recover the original seed phrase.
  • Shares: Parts of the split seed phrase in SSS that do not revealing any information independently.
  • BIP39: A standard used for generating mnemonic seed phrases used in Bitcoin wallets.
  • SLIP39: A variant of BIP39 that supports Shamir’s Secret Sharing.

Now that you have armed yourself with the knowledge to secure your seed phrase effectively, get ready to delve deeper into the fascinating world of cryptocurrencies in the next lesson.

Continue to Next Lesson

Stay tuned as we continue our exploration in the Crypto Is FIRE (CFIRE) training program, bridging traditional financial wisdom with innovative blockchain solutions!

 

 

 

Metal Seed Storage: Best Practices That Last a Lifetime

The Art of Safeguarding Your Digital Wealth

In the world of cryptocurrency, where fortunes can rise and fall with the click of a button, safeguarding your seed phrase isn’t just important—it’s vital! Imagine this: you finally invest in your dream Bitcoin stash only to lose it all because you skimped on backup storage. Terrifying, right? This lesson delves into the crucial topic of metal seed phrase storage solutions, comparing budget-friendly and high-end options, and revealing how much you really need to protect your digital assets effectively.

By the end of this lesson, you will be able to:

  • Identify reliable seed phrase storage solutions: Learn about the best products available that can withstand extreme conditions.
  • Understand the testing methodology: Know how these devices are evaluated against heat, corrosion, and physical damage.
  • Analyze the results: Become adept at sorting through data to make informed purchasing decisions based on specifics.
  • Explore cost-effective DIY options: Discover how to create your own secure storage device without breaking the bank.

So, grab your notepad, and let’s ensure your crypto investments will weather any storm!

Comparison of Metal Seed Phrase Storage Solutions

This lesson will explore the comparative analysis of metal seed phrase devices, highlighting the results from extensive testing conducted by Jameson Lopp on 49 different devices.

The theme revolves around durability and functionality—two essential components for proper seed phrase storage. Each device was rigorously assessed for its ability to withstand extreme heat, corrosive substances, and physical damage. The findings revealed a spectrum of reliability, providing insights into which options prove worthy of a place in your security arsenal.

Steps to Follow: Choosing Your Seed Phrase Storage Solution

The process of selecting an effective seed phrase storage option involves understanding product categories and their respective strengths and weaknesses. Here are the key steps derived from the lessons outlined:

  1. Identify Categories of Devices: Understand the six methods that passed all tests:

    • Handwritten with an electrical dremel.
    • Metal stamping with a hammer.
    • Manual engraving with a sharp tip.
    • Using a mini acid bath for deep scratches.
    • Punching with a hammer and punch.
    • Stacking pre-made letter tiles on a holder.
  2. Test Exposures: Each device was subjected to tests simulating real-world threats:

    • Heat Exposure: Heated to 2000°F for 10 minutes.
    • Corrosion Testing: Exposed to strong acid for 12 hours.
    • Physical Stress: Crushed under a hydraulic press.
  3. Evaluate Performance: Record the outcomes of each test:

    • Tile Devices: Generally failed due to warping and letter displacement.
    • Punch Devices: Most successful, resilient to damage.
  4. Filter Products: Focus on options rated B or higher by Jameson to ensure you choose reliable products.

  5. Price Comparison: Check various pricing structures, including devices with and without tools. Consider bulk purchases for cost-effectiveness.

  6. Review Data Concealment: Understand the implications of visible data if tampering is suspected.

These steps will arm you with the knowledge necessary to secure your cryptocurrency investments gracefully and effectively.

Deeper Analysis: Strengths, Weaknesses, and Everything in Between

The comprehensive analysis of seed phrase storage highlights several standout features that make metal devices essential for cryptocurrency security.

  1. Durability Under Extreme Conditions: The testing regime included extreme temperatures, corrosive acids, and mechanical forces. “Most punch devices did amazing,” demonstrating that these methods are more robust against wear.

  2. Variety of Storage Options: The evidence implies there’s no one-size-fits-all solution. The “punch category” emerged as the most reliable, while tile storage repeatedly faltered, which can be crucial for informed decision-making.

  3. Adaptive Cost Solutions: Lopp’s investigation revealed alternatives that cater to various budgets, from budget-friendly DIY solutions like the SAFU ninja method to pricier, aesthetically pleasing options such as the CryptoTag.

  4. Pragmatic Testing: Lopp emphasizes that “a backup is not a backup until it’s been tested.” This mantra serves as a crucial reminder that verification is key to assuming any backup’s reliability.

While these points paint a compelling case, it’s valid to acknowledge some potential weaknesses. For instance, some DIY methods might seem overly labor-intensive or may sacrifice aesthetics for utility—a point worth considering depending on individual preferences.

Surviving the Heat: The Essential Guide to Seed Phrase Security

The connection between the seed phrase storage discussion and the broader cryptocurrency ecosystem is profound and significant. Seed phrases are critical in the context of owning, transferring, or restoring digital assets, making their storage paramount.

One notable example is the use of steel washers in DIY solutions. This method ensures that an individual can create a scalable and long-lasting storage solution that significantly reduces the risks associated with conventional paper backups, which can be easily destroyed by fire or water damage.

Moreover, the emergence of decentralized finance (DeFi) adds another layer of complexity to the discussion. As users become more immersed in DeFi platforms, the need for secure seed phrase management escalates. Ensuring that seed phrases are stored safely in hardware or through reliable services could potentially prevent unauthorized access to users’ crypto wallets.

Wider Outlook and Impact

As cryptocurrency adoption grows, the dialogue surrounding seed phrase security will likely take center stage. Modern financial literacy demands individuals understand not only how to invest but also how to protect their digital wealth against loss. This is especially relevant considering the increasing trend of hacks and scams in the crypto realm.

Looking ahead, we might witness developments in more advanced storage technologies, potentially incorporating biometric or multi-signature security to further safeguard assets. The integration of blockchain technology into traditional finance also underscores the need for robust security solutions, as digital currencies cannot be entrusted to the same custodial practices that have characterized traditional banking.

Personal Commentary and Insights

As an expert in finance and technology, my exploration into seed phrase storage has illuminated many paths toward optimizing personal security. The fragility of traditional methods highlights an imperative need to reframe our approach to wealth storage in the digital age.

The significant variance in product effectiveness reinforces a principle I often emphasize: due diligence is crucial. While there’s an array of aesthetically designed options, you must prioritize what provides the best security first and foremost.

Conclusion

Safeguarding your seed phrase is not just a precaution; it’s a non-negotiable strategy for crypto enthusiasts who wish to secure their assets. The detailed insights into various storage options provided in this lesson equip you with the knowledge necessary to make informed choices.

As the cryptocurrency landscape continues to evolve, so too must our strategies for securing it. Remember, every decision you make today could have lasting implications for your financial future. Let’s navigate this journey into the next lesson of the Crypto Is FIRE (CFIRE) training program.

Quotes:

  1. “A backup is not a backup until it’s been tested.”
  2. “Most punch devices did amazing.”
  3. “The reason some people might want this is so that they can put it in a tamper evidence bag.”

 

 

Best Practices for Securing Your Seed Phrase

When it comes to safeguarding your cryptocurrency investments, few aspects are as crucial as your seed phrase – the gateway to your digital wallet. In today’s lesson, we will delve into effective methods for storing seed phrases using metal devices that provide durable protection against various challenges, including heat, corrosion, and physical damage. Given the vulnerabilities associated with traditional storage options, understanding the best practices in both traditional finance and crypto is vital for newcomers navigating the increasingly digital landscape. By reinforcing your knowledge in this area, you align your strategies with the Crypto Is FIRE (CFIRE) training plan, equipping yourself for long-term success.

Comparison of Metal Seed Phrase Storage Solutions

  1. Seed Phrase

    • Traditional Finance: A seed phrase (or mnemonic phrase) in the context of traditional finance does not exist, but password security can be compared to personal identification numbers (PINs) or passcodes used for bank accounts.
    • Crypto Application: In the crypto world, a seed phrase is a series of words generated by your wallet that allows you to recover funds if you lose access to your device.
    • Importance: Understanding how seed phrases work helps prevent loss of access and ensures the safety of your digital assets.
  2. Durability Testing

    • Traditional Finance: Conventional financial instruments aren’t tested for environmental durability.
    • Crypto Application: Seed phrase storage devices undergo rigorous testing against extreme conditions, like heat and corrosion, to determine their longevity.
    • Importance: This knowledge enables users to select reliable storage solutions that withstand external threats.
  3. BIP39

    • Traditional Finance: There is no direct equivalent in traditional finance, but BIP39 can be compared to the concept of account recovery options, which need to be secured.
    • Crypto Application: BIP39 defines the method of generating a mnemonic seed phrase consisting of 12 to 24 words, allowing for secure wallet recovery.
    • Importance: Familiarity with BIP39 ensures users understand how to manage and recover their wallets effectively.
  4. DIY Solutions

    • Traditional Finance: Custom DIY solutions don’t regularly apply in traditional finance scenarios.
    • Crypto Application: Users can create their seed phrase storage solutions using metal washers or stainless steel materials.
    • Importance: Understanding DIY options can save costs while providing adequate data protection.
  5. Shamir Secret Sharing

    • Traditional Finance: The concept of distributing shares among trusted parties can be likened to joint accounts or shared custodial agreements.
    • Crypto Application: Shamir Secret Sharing splits a seed phrase into multiple parts, requiring a subset to restore the wallet, thus enhancing security.
    • Importance: This technique adds an additional layer of security for serious investors by spreading exposure.

Key Steps in Seed Phrase Storage

1. Understanding the Importance of a Seed Phrase

  • Importance of securing your seed phrase.
  • Recognize the methods of storage (metal devices or DIY solutions).
  • Awareness of vulnerabilities associated with poorly secured seed phrases.

Detailed Explanation: Your seed phrase, often consisting of 12 to 24 words, serves as the critical access point to your cryptocurrency wallet. It is imperative to understand that losing this phrase can result in the irreversible loss of assets. Simply writing the phrase on paper can expose you to potential theft, fire, or water damage. This is where metal storage devices come into play, providing a robust alternative designed to survive extreme conditions.

2. Overview of Durability Testing Methods

  • Jameson Lopp’s extensive testing on 49 devices.
  • Categories such as Punch, Tile, and DIY solutions.
  • Awareness of failures during rigorous testing.

Detailed Explanation: Jameson Lopp has pioneered the testing of seed phrase storage devices, attempting exposure to extreme environments, including a 2000-degree Fahrenheit flame, which mimics real-life scenarios like house fires. Devices are then doused in cold water to replicate sudden temperature changes, followed by acid testing to evaluate resistance against corrosion. Interestingly, the tile category often succumbs to failure, whereas punch devices tend to succeed, offering a significant lesson for users on which categories to prioritize when selecting a storage solution.

3. Evaluating Your Options

  • Length and complexity of each device.
  • Comparing prices and styles.
  • Consideration of data concealment advantages.

Detailed Explanation: When choosing a device, cost is an important factor, but it should not overrule durability. Devices like the Bitplate Domino are touted as efficient, affordable options for users, whereas the CryptoTag stands as a premium choice. Weighing these criteria against levels of accessibility and peace of mind underscores the importance of making informed decisions that align with your security needs.

4. The DIY Approach

  • Utilizing affordable materials like stainless steel.
  • Implementing the SAFU ninja method with washers.
  • Importance of proper material selection (avoid aluminum).

Detailed Explanation: For the cost-conscious, DIY methods can provide a reliable alternative to more expensive options. By employing methods like using stainless steel washers to store seed phrases, users can achieve delightful scalability. The SAFU ninja method, which involves stamping the first four letters of each BIP39 word onto multiple washers, is particularly effective. Choosing sturdy materials, like 304 stainless steel, ensures durability over time.

A Blockchain Perspective

Crypto Connection: Durability Testing

In the crypto ecosystem, durability testing, as exemplified by Jameson Lopp’s methods, sets a higher standard for how we assess information security compared to traditional financial systems. Certain crypto projects advocate for the production of resistant and secure hardware that people can trust with their assets.

Crypto Connection: BIP39 and DIY Solutions

The principles behind BIP39 have driven forward the conversation around wallet access and recovery. In conjunction, the DIY creative outlet allows savvy crypto investors to align their financial decisions with their budget without compromising security.

Real-World Applications

Historically, the loss of seed phrases has led to countless sobering stories of financial ruin, and conversely, robust storage mechanisms have allowed fortunate few to regain access to lost assets. Much like ensuring your offline bank account or valuables are safely secured, establishing methods for seed phrase protection mirrors those same principles, ensuring that neither traditional nor digital wealth is left to chance.

Challenges and Solutions

  1. Challenges in Selection:
    • Limited understanding of product reliability can lead to losses.
  2. Unique Crypto Challenges:
    • Vulnerabilities to theft or loss remain key concerns.
  3. Solutions Through Education:
    • Knowledge of testing results provides clarity in decision-making.

Key Takeaways

  1. A seed phrase is a form of access code to digital assets; securing it is crucial.
  2. Understanding the durability of seed storage options can save you from potential losses.
  3. Employing BIP39 principles protects your investment’s integrity.
  4. DIY options deliver affordable and scalable methods for seed phrase protection.
  5. Shamir Secret Sharing provides additional layers of protection for serious investors.
  6. The importance of testing backups ensures reliability in recovering accounts.

As you embark on your cryptocurrency journey, applying these insights will help solidify your security strategies, ensuring that your investments remain safe.

Discussion Questions and Scenarios

  1. How does the durability of seed phrase storage devices impact your confidence in the crypto space?
  2. Compare the levels of security offered by traditional banking systems to that of cryptocurrency seed phrase protections.
  3. What are the advantages and disadvantages of using DIY methods for storing seed phrases?
  4. How might the Shamir Secret Sharing model change the way you currently store sensitive information?
  5. Reflecting on your financial literacy journey, how does learning about seed phrases enhance your understanding of digital finance?
  6. Consider various market scenarios; how might failing to test your seed phrase backup affect your strategy in crypto investing?
  7. If you had $1,000 to secure your crypto assets, how would you allocate that budget between devices and DIY solutions?

Glossary

  • Seed Phrase: A sequence of words used in cryptocurrency to recover access to a digital wallet.
  • Durability Testing: Rigorous trials conducted to assess how well storage devices withstand extreme environmental challenges.
  • BIP39: A standard for mnemonic phrases used in generating seed phrases for wallets.
  • Shamir Secret Sharing: A cryptographic method for dividing a secret into shares, requiring a subset to reconstruct.
  • DIY Solutions: Cost-effective, custom-made methods for securing data using everyday materials.

With this grounded approach to securing your seed phrase, you’ll be well on your way to comfortable investment in the digital financial arena.

Continue to Next Lesson

Armed with the knowledge from today’s lesson, let’s delve deeper into securing your financial future as we explore the next topic in the Crypto Is FIRE (CFIRE) training program. Happy learning, and see you in the next session!

 

Read Video Transcript
How to Securely Store Your Seed Phrase: 2/3 split or SSS (Shamir Secret Sharing) 
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TGgBlwrGejg
Transcript:
 In this video, you will learn what Shamir secret sharing is and how it can drastically increase the security of your crypto.  You’ll also learn why this is superior to homemade methods such as splitting your seed phrase into a 2 out of 3 system.  So, why would you want to do that?  Because your seed phrase represents a single point of failure.
 A precise hit will start a chain reaction which should destroy the station.  If it gets stolen, an attacker now has your funds. Or if you lose it, you are denied access to those funds.  So how can you store your seed phrase in a more secure, robust, and distributed way?  Should you scramble it? Encrypt it? Store it out of order? Split it? Do a two out of three system?  The problem with most of these systems is they come from self-appointed experts.
 Watching a lot of football doesn’t make you an offensive coordinator, and using crypto doesn’t make you a cryptographer. So rather than listening to me or some other  random internet opinion, you should listen to Adi Shamir. Adi Shamir is an Israeli cryptographer  who came up with SSS, or Shamir Secret Sharing Scheme, and it is the only truly cryptographically  safe way to store your seed phrase in a distributed way.
 Before we talk about SSS though,  how it works, and how to do it, it’s worth talking about the homemade version of SSS, the 2 out of 3 method.  This is the method you will probably run into most frequently in online forums.  Here’s how it works.  You split your 24 seed phrase into three parts, part A, B, and C.
 Then, you recombine each  part into three shared units, unit AB, BC, and AC.  Since each unit only has 16 of the 24 words, any one part is not enough to steal your seed  phrase.  But if you combine any two of the three units, you get your full 24 words again.  It’s an honest attempt at trying to get around the single point of failure, but please don’t  do this.
 Your gut response might be to think that it reduces your security by two thirds since you reduce 24 random words to only eight random words.  But because you’re choosing from a list of 2048 words 24 different times versus only  eight times, it’s actually trillions of trillions of times worse.
 A random set of 24 words is  considered 256 bits of security. A random set of only eight words is considered  only 80 bits of security. So even though 80 bits is way worse than 256 bits is 80 bits  of security still good enough. People online argue about this a lot. Some people say it  is and some people say it isn’t just Google 80 bit security if you want to go down that  rabbit hole. But the point I’m making is that you don’t have to settle for 80 bits of security when instead you could keep all 256 bits of security and still get the
 flexibility offered by seed splitting. It’s called Shamir secret sharing scheme. Adi Shamir, the man  who came up with SSS also helped come up with RSA encryption. The S and RSA stands for Shamir. So  he’s a pretty big deal.
 SSS allows you to split your secret phrase into as many parts as you’d like without  revealing any information to anyone until they gather enough parts to meet the threshold.  First, you decide how many parts you want to split your seed phrase into, called shares.  And then you decide how many shares will be required to recover the seed, called the threshold.  A share, like you are used to with a regular seed phrase, is just a list of words.
 But rather than using the BIP39 word list and being 24 words long, it uses the SLIP39  word list and is usually 20 words long for each share.  So if you split it up into 6 shares and you decide you need 3 to recover it, then the  threshold is 3.  If an attacker is lucky enough to get his hands on only two parts,  then they still don’t have any information about your seed phrase  because the shares don’t give away any information  until the full threshold is reached.
 This is the brilliantly amazing part of the Shamir sharing scheme.  If you don’t have the full threshold, you don’t have anything.  Even if you were just one share off from the threshold,  an attacker would still have to brute force the full 256 bits of security.  But how does that work?  To be honest, the math involved is way out of my league, but I’ll do my best to explain  a simplified version.
 It all comes down to math and polynomials.  Let’s say your secret recovery phrase was represented by a curvy line on a graph, a  mathematical function called a polynomial.  In this example, to know 100%  what the equation of that line is, we need to have three data points. But what if we  erase one of the data points? Can we draw our line? Unfortunately, we can’t, because  we end up being able to draw an infinite number of solutions for lines that go through those  two dots. So we are just left with guessing through an infinite number of possibilities.
 It’s not until we get the third data point where we can successfully recover the equation for our line and with our third data point  We can solve for our equation and recover the keys to our account without the full threshold of points an attacker has an infinite number  Of solutions and therefore the information is useless  This is what makes the Shamir secret sharing scheme so powerful you choose the number of of shares you want, then you choose how many data points are required to be able  to recover your account. This not only protects you from attackers, but it also protects you
 if you lose a couple of shares. Right now, if you want to use SSS, it’s only compatible  with Trezor and Keystone. I’ve read about several hardware wallets with plans to implement  it in the future, and when they do, I’ll let you guys know in the comments. I really  hope more hardware wallets implement it in the future because it’s incredibly powerful.
 Even after watching this whole video though, you might just decide that SSS isn’t for you and that’s okay.  The best protection is the one that you understand and can implement the best.  So if you’re not confident you could set it up and recover it correctly, it’s better not to use it in the first place.

 

Best Metal Seed Phrase Storage Comparison (Cheap VS Expensive)

Transcript:

 If you want to store your seed phrase on a metal device to make sure it will last a lifetime,  what are the best options?  Unfortunately, a lot of expensive seed phrase storage devices get annihilated  when it comes to heat, corrosion, and physical damage,  the exact things they’re supposed to protect against.

 So which products will last and which won’t?  And do you have to shell out $100 or can you get a bomb-proof option for much cheaper?  Luckily, a guy named Jameson Lopp has already rigorously tested  49 different seed phrase devices against heat, corrosion, and physical damage. After spending  several hours reading and cataloging all the results into a more searchable and sortable  spreadsheet, this video will condense the time it takes you to digest all the information on  its website. In addition, with the spreadsheet I’ve made, you’ll be able to sort by all the

 different parameters that matter to you like device style, whether or not the data is concealed  for tamper evidence, the grade it received on each test, the price, the price with tools,  and the price for three separate devices if you need multiple.  Most of that information isn’t searchable or sortable from Jameson’s website, but I’ve  got to give credit where credit is due, and it all goes to him.

 On the spreadsheet, I’ve only listed the products that are still available for purchase.  Some products have doubled in price since Jameson originally posted, so you can be confident  that what you are seeing on my spreadsheet has the up-to-date information.  If you’re watching this video a year from now, let me know if anything is out of date,  and I’ll update the spreadsheet as well as include the revision date for everyone’s benefit.

 Now let’s summarize the results.  There are six categories of devices that passed all the tests.  handwritten with an electrical dremel.  taking a metal stamp and hammering the letters onto plates.  similar to engraving but not motorized, just scratching your letters with a really  sharp tip.  One method even uses a mini acid bath to deepen the scratches.

 using a hammer and punch to make holes or deep indents on a plate,  stacking, by stacking pre-made letters onto a rod, and finally, tiles, where you sort  pre-made letter tiles onto a metal holder.  To prove each device could stand the test of time, Jameson exposed each one to a 2000  degree Fahrenheit flame for 10 minutes, then dunked them in cold water after to simulate  a house fire and sudden cool down that would come from firefighters putting out the fire.

 Then Jameson put them in strong acid for 12 hours to make sure they could withstand corrosion,  then crushed them under a hydraulic press, just for good measure.  The category that failed the most frequently was the tile category.  The heat caused the devices to warp in non-uniform ways and tiles would pop out of place, leading  to permanent data loss.

 The acid had similar effects, and if it passed the first two tests, then the compression  and bending in the third test would pop the tiles out of place even more.  Only two tile devices passed all the tests, Symbit and CypherWheel.  Beyond those two, this is the category I’d avoid.  The category that succeeded the most frequently was the Punch category.

 Big indents and chunky pieces of metal is difficult data to erase or obscure.  The only time this category ran into problems was when the lines delineating the data wasn’t  deeply engraved enough.  Then you’d have a harder time determining what letter or number each indent corresponded  to.  This was rare, though, and most punch devices did amazing.

 As for the rest of the categories, some products did great while others did poorly.  It was just more product specific.  To help narrow your decision, I’ve only included products on the spreadsheet that were rated  a B or higher by Jameson.  You might start by sorting the spreadsheet by price, then sorting by device style.

 When you do this, you’ll get a comment-only version of my spreadsheet.  So to properly sort the spreadsheet, click a column, then Data, Sort Sheet through A  to Z. Then, edit your temporary Sort Sheet through A to Z.  Then, edit your temporary filter by changing A1 to A2.  This will put filters on top of each column so you can sort by whatever field you want.

 The reason there are four different price categories is because I thought it would be  helpful to know the costs with and without tools.  Do you already own metal stamps, a punch, or an engraver?  Or do you know someone you could borrow it from?  I also calculated the cost of purchasing three devices because I wanted to see how well the  costs scaled.

 If you want multiple backups, or you choose to do a Shamir secret sharing  scheme, then it’s important to know how much buying three will cost. You can also sort  by currency because products listed in your local currency will probably have reduced  shipping costs.  I also want to explain what the Data Concealed column means.  This refers to whether or not an onlooker could just see the data by looking at the  device.

 The reason some people might want this is so that they can put it in a tamper evidence  bag to know if the data has ever been exposed while in storage.  If Jameson adds more test results in the future, I’ll be sure to add them in.  After spending hours with all the different results, I have some recommendations.

 If you’re looking for a one-and-done solution, easy to set up, easy to read, bomb proof,  I’d get the Bitplate Domino. Specifically, the Bitplate Domino 1, because that way you  don’t have to do any of the double dot patterns required for smaller bitplate options. But  if the double dot pattern doesn’t bother you, then you can get one of the cheaper bitplate  options. Currently, it is 55 euros for the Domino One and €40 for the Pocket Domino.

 If you want something that will take the least amount of time and hassle to set up, then  the Black Seed Ink Plate is a great option.  Basically, just write your letters while pressing hard.  You can tell from the pictures it’s not quite as bomb-proof as some of the other options,  but it definitely passed all the tests.

 It retails for $27, and if you buy three, it only comes out to $16 apiece.  If you are going for the cool factor, then CryptoTag is a sleek-looking option.  It’s expensive though, currently retailing for $129.  Ouch.  Kind of feels like you’re paying for marketing because, according to Jameson’s tests, it  doesn’t seem like there’s any additional security in comparison to a typical punch plate.

 Also, Zeus, which is the cheaper of the two, has you store the BIP39 numbers rather than  storing the first four letters of your BIP39 words.  So there’s a higher chance of a transcription error than just saving the first four letters  of each word.  The version that lets you stamp the letters rather than the numbers is the Thor, the $350  option.

 If you’ve never used a seed storage device before, you might be confused as to why some  devices only let you store the first four letters of each word. You will need the full word when you go to restore your account,  so why only store a part of the data? The reason is because the words have a special  property. There are no two words that will ever share the first four letters.

 So, to  save space, you don’t need to store the whole word. To see this list, go look up the  BIP39 word list. If you’re cheap, like me, then I’d go for the SAFU ninja  method. You buy 24 stainless steel washers, then stamp a number onto it for your word order,  then the first four letters of each word onto each washer.

 You can also buy a stamp guide to  make hammering the stamps in easier and look a lot more appealing. This is also the most scalable  solution because you can get washers even cheaper if you buy them in bulk. Another cheap DIY or  do-it-yourself option is the Safe Seed DIY, which is also relatively cheap.  In general, for DIY solutions, you’re looking for stainless steel, copper, or titanium.

 Just make sure to avoid aluminum because of corrosion and warping at temperature.  If you do go with stainless steel, I’d try to stick to a 304 stainless steel.  For reference, that is what is used in the Sappho Ninja test with the washers.  Grade 304 stainless steel is great against corrosion but won’t survive being stored  long term in saltwater.

 I’m not quite sure why you’d want to do that, but if you did and you were some scuba  diving pirate treasure hunter, then research grade 316 stainless steel or other marine  solutions.  Another product from Jameson’s test I feel is worth mentioning is the Crypto Key Stack.  I feel like it got a lot of things right.

 It looks cool  You can buy it with or without the logo and it comes with an electric graver all for $45 and it performed great on  All the tests. So those are my recommendations  Feel free to look through the rest of the spreadsheet to see if there’s an option you’d like better if you’re watching this video  Then it means you’re serious about securing your crypto  So please remember this a backup is not a backup until it’s been tested  If you haven’t tested your words to properly restore your account, a backup is not a backup until it’s been tested. If you

 haven’t tested your words to properly restore your account, then it’s not a true backup because you  may have written it down wrong. Don’t trust yourself that you did it right. Verify it so  you can be 100% sure. And while we’re on the topic of securing our seed phrase, I’d recommend  learning two more concepts if you aren’t familiar with them already.

 Go look up what a BIP39 passphrase is, called a 25th word, and what a Shamir secret sharing  scheme is.  Of the two, Shamir is my favorite, but they are both used to protect against different  scenarios.  Good luck securing your crypto, and thanks for watching.